Thursday, March 11, 2010

The Pat Buchanan of France?

Gérard Longuet, majority leader in the French Senate, let one slip yesterday when he rejected the nomination of a French official of North African descent to head the High Authority Against Discrimination and For Equality, saying he was not "of traditional French descent." As offensive as the comments of our own majority leader regarding the president's skin tone were, these comments are of a different order of magnitude and cut straight to the core of the debate over national identity that has gripped the country.

The full quote was this: "It is better that the head be of traditional French descent, someone who will feel a greater burden to welcome all of our compatriots. Examples would be natives of Brittany and Lorraine -- who are mostly of Italian or Moroccan descent -- who struggle to open themselves up to outsiders. If you make only a symbolic nomination, someone actually from the outside, you risk endangering the mission."   

Somewhere in there, you can make out the point he is trying to make: that since it is "traditional" French who struggle most with integration, naming someone from a "traditional" background would do most to evoke their sympathies. The irony, of course, is that by excluding the nominee, Malek Boutih -- a former head of SOS Racisme and a functionary in the Socialist Party who was born in France -- from the "corps francais traditionnel" (the term he actually used), he is preempting the very mission he is ostensibly attempting to defend.

Reaction has been strong and swift, with one anti-discrimination association declaring "the return of psychologically repressed racism," while others have accused him of attempting to advance the UMP's efforts to to siphon off votes from the Front national. 

Ultimately this will amount to a mini-crisis, with no serious long-term implications--indeed, none of the coverage of the incident was among LeMonde's top 10 most viewed stories this morning. But each new incident like this further widens the trust gap between France's minority and majority populations.